The film tells the story of holly martins, trying to uncover the truth about his friend, harry limes, death. Nominated for several academy awards, the third man won best cinematography for robert krasker. The director carol reed, chose to have the characters of holly martins and harry lime discuss there endeavours on a large ferris wheel. Sd,29 min this german retrospective commemorates the 50th anniversary of the third man. The third man theme also known as the harry lime theme is an instrumental written and performed by anton karas for the soundtrack to the 1949 film the third man. And he insisted on karas zither music the third man theme was one of 1950s biggest hits. Many critics consider the third man to be the best british postworld war ii film.
According to the internet movie database, 1949s the third man is the only nonamerican film to have made the american film institutes top 100 films of all time, and ranks number one in the british film institutes bfi 100, a similar list compiled in 1999. He had previously adapted his own work his story the basement room became 1948s the fallen idol, also directed by the third mans carol reed, as well as the work of other writers 1940s 21 days together, based on john galsworthys play the first and. Third man definition is an offside fielding position in cricket usually near the boundary and roughly in line with third slip and the striker. The striking film noirish, shadowy thriller was filmed expressionistically within the decadent. Details some of the qualities traditionaly associated with film noir. In this article i will provide a philosophical analysis of carol reeds 1949 film the third man. The third man 1949 is a visuallystylish thriller a paranoid story of social, economic, and moral corruption in a depressed, rotting and crumbling, 20th century vienna following world war ii. Visual meaning in the third man through the contents of the image and the resources of montage, the cinema has at its disposal a whole arsenal of means whereby to impose its interpretation of an event on the spectator. The third man in question is portrayed wonderfully by orson welles, who conveys a tragic man who wants to be left alone and hold onto schmidt, his love. Revisiting carol reeds timeless thriller, the third man, once voted the greatest british film of all time. Rollo martins, who is a writer of books, arrives in vienna.
The film is currently available in both an american and british release version. It features a convoluted plot rooted in the banality of. There are others myself included who believe it to be one of the bestever examples of film noir to come out of all of europe. Graham greene the third man fairground scene genius. Immediately download the the third man summary, chapterbychapter analysis, book notes, essays, quotes, character descriptions, lesson plans, and more everything you need for studying or teaching the third man. How does the director of the third man use camera work, mise en scene and sound to create claustrophobia and disorientation within the sewer chase scene.
The classic film noir conventions are shown within this scene with the harsh shadows and chiaroscuro lighting. Third man definition of third man by merriamwebster. By the time that i began to screen the third man 1949 for college students in 1990, orson welles 19151985 was already a largely forgotten director and. In 1949, it won the grand prix at cannes and the best british film award bafta. Cotten had been a stage star on broadway before beginning a long association with orson welles, who cast him in both citizen kane us, 1941 and the magnificent ambersons. The third man as a story and a film by graham greene hese observations on story writing and films were written by mr. The third man reflects the optimism of americans and the boneweariness of europe after the war. Also nominated for best director and film editing, the third mans legend far eclipses the oscars.
Keith phipps and scott tobias of will lead an mbt talks discussion of the third man, hosted by the chicago film critics association and the music box, following the 7. Essay about the third man, historical analysis 1550. The third man 1949 is one of that handful of motion pictures rashomon, casablanca, the searchers that have become archetypesnot merely a movie that would go on to influence myriad other. The films antagonist, harry lime, remains unseen during the first two thirds of the third man, however. The third man is a 1949 british film noir directed by carol reed, written by graham greene, and starring joseph cotten, alida valli, orson welles, and trevor howard. One of the greatest british films, carol reeds classic very consciously emphasises its. Graham greens taut story and wonderfully snappy dialogue provide a strong foundation for some outstanding performances. While this combination makes the third man an irregular film noir, it still, nevertheless, is a film noir. With the third man, graham greene wrote a book to write a.
Shadowing the third man 2005, a ninetyminute feature documentary on the making of the film. Many critics consider the third man to be the best british postworld war ii film noir. Sooner he discloses that harry lime was the leader of a gang that robbed penicillin from the military hospital to adulterate and resell it, and has caused the death and anomalies in many children. Greene as a preface to his novelette, the third man, to be published tomorrow by viking press.
It is particularly remembered for its atmospheric cinematography, musical score and performances, and has. Someone tells him that his friend harry lime has been the victim of a car accident and his funeral is on the central funeral at this day. Reed has used black and white to generate a noir style film. Get an answer for could anyone help me with the novel the third man by graham greene. The striking filmnoirish, shadowy thriller was filmed expressionistically within the decadent, shattered and poisoned city that has been sectordivided along geopolitical lines. About the third man fairground scene this is one of the most memorable scenes from the 1949 film the third man, directed by carol reed and. Abridged recording of graham greenes treatment, read by actor richard clarke graham greene. He continues to investigate and he has a great surprise when he. The third man is a 1949 british film noir directed by carol reed, written by graham greene. The use of these colours make the atmosphere more threatening.
Holly martins is the principal character in the third man. Selznick and greene originally wanted a happy ending. Set in postwar vienna, the film centres on american holly martins cotton, who arrives in the city to accept a job with his friend harry lime welles, only to learn that lime has died viewing his death as suspicious, martins. The film doesnt ask for sympathy for the killer franz becker, but it asks for understanding. I remember that i wanted to see the film on its first release, but was unable to do so, which created a mystique about the film. Discusses how the film uses specific cinematic techniques which place it in the genre of classic film noir. Elsewhere in the film, an innocent old man, suspected of being the killer, is attacked by a mob that forms on the spot. The third man was not the first screenplay graham greene ever wrote, but it was the first one not based on preexisting material. Footage of modern vienna is interspersed between clips of the film, analysis, interviews, and vintage footage. This film, directed brilliantly by carol reed odd man out, the fallen idol and written by graham greene, who created a long list of memorable cinematic scripts, ingeniously captures the prevailing atmosphere of disruption and chaos that vienna, a once highly civilized city, experienced during the years that followed world war ii. A british film noir, and one of the best british films ever. One night after a long day of filming the third man. So he goes to the funeral by taxi and arrives just before it ends. Reed defied convention by shooting entirely on location in vienna, where mountains of rubble stood next to gaping bomb craters, and the ruins of empire supported a desperate black market economy.
American writer, holly martins, arrives in postwar vienna to visit his old friend harry lime. According to the internet movie database, 1949s the third man is the only nonamerican film to have made the american film. As is typical to the genre of film noir, carol reeds the third man is a film of suspense and intrigue, full of shadows and twisting plots. As he says in his own defense, he cannot escape or control the evil compulsions that overtake him. Culture film features martin scorsese on the third man. However, hes overly idealistic and is a manchild and a idiot hero, though he does grow wiser at the end of the film. This is his primary motivator at the start of the film, since he just found out about harry limes death, which is faked, by the way. The third man 1949 is a visually stylish thriller a paranoid story of social, economic, and moral corruption in a. In one of the many extras in criterions sumptuous dvd presentation of carol reeds the third man, peter bogdanovich calls the film the greatest nonauteur film ever made.
The movie ends as it begins, in a cemetery, and then calloway gives holly a ride back to town. Supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, quotes, and essay topics. An analysis of the film, the third man by carol reed kibin. Several factors contribute to make the third man as powerful and as stunningly original now as it was when it premiered to great acclaim in 1949. The master novelist was hired by producer alexander korda to write a movie set in rome or vienna. The third man, deeply influenced by italian neorealism, is arguably the most significant british example, though it has a close contender in reeds odd man out 1947, shot on blitzed sites in. Common tropes that appear in both film noir and expressionism are the repetitive crime drama, and romances with the sense of scepticism and. The idea that reed was not an auteur, merely a gifted technician, is difficult to credit in light of the directors career and particularly the third man. The third man how reed uses, develops and challenges generic thriller conventions in this noir film.
Im looking for a critical analysis of the novel and its themes. Martins learns that lime faked his death and had been working on the black market, selling dangerously diluted penicillin. It wouldnt be a noir film had the protagonist not been one. The third man won the 1949 grand prix at the cannes film festival, the british academy award for best film, and an academy award for best black and white cinematography in 1950. Carol reeds the third man on criterion bright lights. The third man is both a holly martins shitty bestseller and nietzschean philosophical treatise, entertaining the audience as well as initiating a crisis of faith. The third man was never written to be read but only to be seen. The ferris wheel scene is one of the most important and suspenseful scenes in the third man. This onepage guide includes a plot summary and brief analysis of the third man by graham greene. The final scene in the third man is a long, elegiac sigh. The various changes that were made as the third man evolved from graham greenes original treatment to the final result in carol reeds film, have already been described in some detail by adamson 1984, moss 1987 and wapshott 1990, and will not be outlined here once again only one major change will be mentioned. The third man as part of the barbicans city visions series, were asking you to pick the best city film with the winner to get a special guardian cities screening.
The film was written by graham greene, directed by carol reed, and produced by the american david selznick and. The third man 1949 is a visuallystylish thriller a paranoid story of social, economic, and moral corruption in a. Also nominated for best director and film editing, the third man s legend far eclipses the oscars. The third man a philosophical analysis beats views. British director carol reeds 1949 euronoir the third man is justly famous among movie buffs and film scholars for its. The hunted man, an hourlong, 1968 episode of the bbcs omnibus series, featuring a rare interview with the novelist. After holly discovers more contradictory information that there were three men who carried the body across the road after the accident kurtz, popescu, and a mysterious third man not the doctor, he looks down at the pavement through the upstairs window where people walk in the harsh shadows of the night. English subtitles that default on, but are removable are provided, as this feature has no alternate audio track. The third man analysis the ferris wheel scene ideas. The third man is a 1949 british film noir, directed by carol reed.
327 607 63 1021 258 465 1395 1139 1410 933 666 1245 18 534 1073 1053 280 771 636 676 1259 661 663 320 594 497 862 803 972 509 39 871 1256 1194 1318 1323 924 1119 1210 132 782 423 1099 742 886 158 1083